If you hold yourself tight enough, do you think all of your broken pieces will somehow glue themselves back together? When the hole in your chest opens up again, if you wrap your arms around yourself do you think it’s enough to fill the gap that is now gaping, making your heart feel exposed and vulnerable. The problem with glue is, its only temporary, it doesn’t last. Over time, it weakens and easily gives way, so when you are at the point of breaking, the pieces that were so lovingly held together, crumble and fall apart again.
I loathe people seeing me cry. It’s the ultimate vulnerability for me. I’d rather be stripped naked physically than let people close enough to see me cry. I hate feeling unguarded and exposed, I spent a long time building my walls up, so its something I generally do in private. I suppose this comes from the fear that people will think I’m weak or that they have a responsibility to make things better for me.
For the last however many years, I’ve been so used to gluing my own pieces together, its alien that other people might actually want to help to fix me.
This happened to me today.
After such a positive morning, having spoken to Kirsty and my heart absolutely bursting with pride that Sam is doing so well, and is trying super hard in school, with the most amazing support put in place, I felt content, happy even.
To then a few hours later, that all to come crashing down as that little voice in my head, as it likes to do so often, whispers ‘but you don’t get to keep him’
I know that every moment now counts with Sam, I really do, and I am trying so hard to find the positives in every day. I am so happy that he is doing so well, he is happy and healthy.
But I cannot help that wave of sadness that every so often engulfs me. I feel it pulling and tugging at me for days and no matter how hard I try to fight it, I can’t. I have no option but to give in to it. The only choice I have, is to not let it drown me. I am trying so hard to remember what I was taught about feeling my emotions and letting them pass, but sometimes, it’s harder said than done.
Today I fell apart in front of someone I really care about. My guard appeared to have gone on a permanent holiday and once the tears had started leaking from my eyes, I couldn’t stop them. Right now I’m still disappointed in myself for even allowing that level of vulnerability. But really, when I think about it, is it such a bad thing? Especially when the people who witness my meltdowns, really want to help?
What I need to learn to do, is to replace my glue for stitching. To slowly learn how to sew my pieces back together, with all the love and support I need. However hard it may be to accept that, sometimes, just sometimes, I need help to hold myself together.
And that is not weak, it’s not needy; it’s just what good, honest people do.
So for now I continue to ride the ups and downs, like the merry workings of the most beautiful carousel that is life.
When home no longer feels like home anymore….

When I said my marriage vows, I meant them. Hand on heart, I meant every word of it and I thought that it would be forever. But as you grow, you realise that life sometimes has other plans for you and it’s not always that straightforward. You are then faced with the life changing task of having to make a decision.
I married my husband after we had been in a relationship for 5 years. We had our share of ups and downs, as most young couples do, but I loved him. As with most little girls, getting married had always been something I’d dreamed of, how Id want to be proposed to, where it would be, what would the ring look like. As it turned out, none of it was what I expected. I even chose and ordered my own ring in hope that it would spur him on to propose. Alas, it did not. We eventually did get engaged, after much bribery on my part, which looking back shouldn’t have been needed, had I really been marriage material. After all, who would want to marry someone who was so broken? We eventually set a date for our wedding and much to my pleasure, started planning. In what seemed like a whirlwind the wedding was soon here and gone and we started to settle into married life. It didn’t feel much different really. Until just one short month later, one individuals poor split second decision changed everything.
A road traffic collision involving my husband on a motorcycle and a woman driving a Honda CRV, would see me go very quickly from new bride to carer in the space of just a few weeks.
Very lucky to keep his left leg and now in an external fixator, our lives all of a sudden revolved around hospital visits, clinics sometimes 5 days a week, for full days, for months, physio appointments, district nurse appointments, plastic surgery follow ups, further surgery, complications. With very little in the way of family support, this fell solely on me. We got married 4 weeks ago……what kind of fresh hell was this? I couldn’t quite get my head round it. And of course, I wouldn’t change the fact I was caring for my husband, not in a heartbeat, but our honeymoon period was well and truly out of the window.
Emotionally and physically I gave my absolute all to helping him through this period of time. I pushed him every day to do the best he could, I tried my best to help him heal in any way I could…….but what about me?
I wasn’t the one that was broken, not physically, people wouldn’t ask how I was doing, if I needed any help, did I want to talk? It was a lonely place to be and it never got any easier. To watch someone you care so much for suffer the way he did, broke my heart and more often than not I wished it was me and not him. All I wanted was to make things better.
I felt that while he was in this place, whatever place that was, I couldn’t unload my emotional stress on to him, my best friend and with no one to share the load with, I shut off. And it wasn’t something, for me, that was easy to pick back up again. And once again I felt I was fighting battles by myself, because it was easier than opening up to someone else.
After the accident, over the next 7 years, we were bounced from one trauma to another and we would endure more than most couples would go through in a lifetime of marriage. After Sam’s initial diagnosis, we were barely communicating. As I have mentioned before I was pretty much catatonic. I suggested to him that I was thinking about going to see a counsellor and it went down as well as I expected. He was upset and angry that I wouldn’t talk to him, couldn’t talk to him, yet I was going to pay a complete stranger to sit and listen to me talk for 50 minutes at a time. What I couldn’t make him understand was that there were things I needed to talk about, to be heard without someone being emotionally involved, to let me know my feelings were valid without making it about themselves. And yet over the course of the following months, this is exactly what would happen in my marriage.
The first thing I had to do was to be honest and tell him that after Sam’s hospital appointment, and having hit rock bottom, I had started cutting again. I thought he deserved to know. Self injury, for the most part is secretive. It’s not something we go shouting from the rooftops. I didn’t want him to know. I wanted to deal with this in my own way, and this was what I knew. I thought he would understand, I thought he would support me, I thought he would appreciate that I was being honest with him. But my expectations were not met. After I told him, his first response was anger. This anger was very much aimed at me. He was looking for someone to blame. That then came in the form of a close friend of mine. He blamed her because of a conversation I had with her months before surrounding the topic of self harm. Of course, no one was to blame for me cutting myself, that decision was mine and mine alone.
Thats when the constant looking and searching for marks started. Like I was constantly under surveillance, I felt like I was suffocating. Why couldn’t I talk to him, why didn’t I want to share, what was wrong with him?Why did I talk to my friends but not him?
From the beginning of our relationship, he was aware that I had been abused, as I’d told him that much but I had never divulged any details to him, nor to anyone else. As I saw it, and still do, the details are bad enough in my head, why on earth would anyone else want them in theirs.
The last thing I wanted was for it to change how people felt about me. I didn’t want to be pitied or seen as a victim. And this applied to him too, probably even more so.
The first session I had with Dawn where we addressed the abuse, I was so immensely proud of myself leaving her house that day having finally spoken to someone about it, then arriving home and for that feeling of elation to be short lived. My counselling sessions were between me and Dawn, but when I got back, I was met with a barrage of questions and pushed to a point where I had to relay everything we’d spoken about. This would result in me having to talk about things I wasn’t ready to talk about. Counselling was about finding my voice, why was I letting someone take it from me again?
When eventually I caved in and let him read my letter, detailing just some of the abuse I had endured, he did exactly the thing I had feared the most. He wouldn’t touch me for three weeks. When I asked him about it he told me that it was just as much my fault as his.
All sharing those details had done, was reinforce the fact that I had something to be ashamed of. Of course, why would anyone want to touch me after reading that?
For anyone who has been through counselling they will understand me when I say that you come out of the sessions feeling as though your brain has never worked a day in its life before. They are so cathartic but so exhausting and emotionally draining. The last thing I wanted to do when I got home was to talk about everything again.
Besides that, I just wasn’t ready. In truth, I don’t think I would have ever been ready to share those details with him. I just didn’t want to. After the way he had reacted over the self harm revelation and other various situations, it became apparent that he was no longer a safe place for me anymore. I didn’t feel as though I could talk to him for fear of how he would react. I worried about upsetting him, making him angry, about hurting him. If I opened up he would project his own thoughts and feelings on to me and make it about himself and so I shut down. It was so much easier. And again, not for the first time in my life, I wished the darkness would engulf me. My heart felt so sad and my soul tired. Is this what marriage should feel like? I found myself spending as much time away from home as possible. It didn’t feel like home anymore. All I wanted to do was run and not come back.
Over the following months, I felt so worn down and so torn between doing what was best for everyone else and what was right for me. I am a people pleaser and will do, say and give anything to see other people happy. But at what cost to my own health? My own sanity? I was asked time and time again to give reassurance that we would be ok, but I honestly couldn’t give the answers that were wanted of me, because I just didn’t know.
It only takes something and sometimes, someone to make you stop and really take stock of your life. Just like the day I wrote off my car, it felt as though my life was heading into one big car crash.
After being pushed to my absolute limit one Friday night in September, I had a panic attack outside the girls old dance studio. I felt like the walls were very quickly closing in on me and I couldn’t breathe.
One of my most favourite humans, who very quickly became one of my best friends, has travelled this journey with me from the beginning. She has given me advice, even though I have completely ignored her on occasion and done what I wanted anyway, given me love and her support 100% and talked me out of doing really stupid things, even if it meant just sitting and crying on the phone to each other. She told me honestly that she couldn’t watch me like that anymore, I was miserable and sad all the time and it wasn’t me. I had to make a decision. I knew she was right, and it frightened me, more than anything. I knew what I had to do, but that meant making a decision for myself, and having the courage to follow it through.
I decided that what was right for me, was to walk away from something that refused to help me grow, that would always refuse to help me grow and didn’t want anything to change. But the truth was, I had changed. Quite considerably. I’d found my voice and I still wasn’t being encouraged to use it. I’d become a fuller, more whole version of myself and I realised that I wasn’t happy. And that on reflection, I hadn’t been happy for a very long time. Sometimes, you have to do what you really don’t want to do, because it’s the right thing. The last thing I wanted was to hurt anyone, but in these kinds of situations, someone is always going to get hurt. Of course people will always have their own opinions as to why I left a marriage that from the outside looked strong and healthy, but they weren’t living it behind closed doors. Let them talk, let them listen to rumours, let them paint me out to be the ‘bad guy’. What they think isn’t important.
My truth is that I want a happy life, one lived to the fullest, with no regrets, filled with love, laughter and appreciation for exactly who I am. I don’t want the world, I never did. What I really wanted the most was to be seen, to be heard, to be held.
I just want the new chapter in my book of life to be a happy one.
A second date with Battens….
Still trapped in that terrifying nightmare of just over a month ago, some days I feel like I have my life on track, I feel like I’m doing ok, I’m holding it together. And then other days I feel as though the weight of the world is on my shoulders, that I’m not built to handle this, Im not strong enough and all it takes is for someone to say something kind to me and I lose it. I suppose this is how life is going to be for the foreseeable future, riding the rollercoaster with all its ups and downs, twists and turns. How I wish I could get off this ride. As I sit in my safe place on the kitchen work top, I can’t help but question again, what is my actual life?
The appointment with Dr Parker still doing laps in my ever overactive brain, and still sitting on the test results coming back from mine and Sam’s dads genetic testing, it felt what I imagined waiting to be hung drawn and quartered felt like.
I would take the phone call from the hospital yesterday. I honestly had no idea that the results would be coming at me in that form. My phone vibrating against the sofa, no caller ID. I answered and it was Jo, the genetic counsellor who works with Dr Parker. After the niceties were out of the way, she told me that they had the results back from mine and Luke’s blood tests. The results confirmed what they thought, that I carry half the genetic default responsible for CLN3, Luke carried the other half. Together we had given both faulty halves to Sam, resulting in the full genetic default that is Batten disease. The chances of this happening are less than winning the lottery. Why us?
I cannot begin to describe the insurmountable guilt I felt as soon as the words echoed down the phone. Although its the result we were told to expect, to have it confirmed was like a slap in the face.
I was half responsible for giving my son this life sentence he’d been handed.
My heart that had been doing so well at holding itself together in the last couple of weeks, started to tear itself up again. The weight of responsibility feels too much to bare and today my heart feels incredibly sad. As a parent you do anything to protect your children, and yet through pure chance, we had given Sam this. It’s so difficult not to place blame on yourself. And even though I know that there is absolutely nothing we can do to change this now, would we have done things differently had we known?
Now not for one minute would I change Sam, but what I would give to spare him what is to come.
So my second date with Battens had ended pretty much the same as the first. With my heart feeling bruised and hurting.
The thing with genetic counselling is that even though it is necessary, no matter how many people tell you it’s not your fault, there’s nothing that you could have done, there’s nothing that you can do, there is always going to be a natural element of blame. And the blame lies very heavily on myself at the moment, and I think that is a very natural reaction given the circumstances.
So for now, I will go back to trying to hold my broken pieces together the best I can for my family and hope that I can still give them all the love they need and deserve.
A letter speaks a thousand words……

*Trigger warning* Abuse
When I first started writing my blog, I honestly didn’t know what route it was going to take. I didn’t know where to start, until I bought a new laptop one day and sat and began to type.
Primarily, this blog was to document our journey with sam, but, it has started to become so much more than that. Within the safety of these pages I have been able to share other experiences from my life that I feel people really need to talk about more. Miscarriage, abuse, mental health problems; taboo subjects that people know about but don’t want to discuss. I know to some that are reading these things about me, perhaps for the first time, it may come across as dark and depressing, but in reality, this is the life I was given and this is my story of how I chose to live it.
I am so incredibly touched at the amount of people who have reached out to me to not only offer their support, love and wisdom, on each and every subject I have posted about, but to then open up and share their own experiences with me, to empathise with the stories I have to tell, has been beyond heart warming. If writing can reach out and help just one person, for whatever reason they might need; to see their worth, to know that they are seen, heard, validated, it has been absolutely worth it.
In this blog post I am going to share something that I wrote for one of my counselling sessions. Something that I found so incredibly empowering and although it was written at a time where my life was pretty much still upside down, it was done with the most clarity I have ever felt. To know that what happened to me, does not define me, does not own me, does not rule my past nor my future.
This session was sparked by a conversation I had with my middle child, Scarlett. Anyone who knows me, knows that I have always been a stickler for teaching my children body autonomy. From as soon as they could understand I have always taught them that their bodies are their own, no one is allowed to touch them without their say so, they don’t have to kiss/hug/touch anyone if they don’t want to, they are more than entitled to their own space and they have the ability to say no. I love that they all have their own voice and encourage them to use it as often as I can……sometimes this does backfire when I’m faced with the attitude of three small people who think they are teenagers. I am however a very strong believer that this is something that we should all be talking to our children about, encouraging them to be open, making them aware of their own bodies, aware of their feelings, acknowledging their feelings, allowing them their own personal space, and teaching them that they have their own rights to these things, even as little people. Because little people, very quickly grow to be big people. And these lessons shape who we become.
Now although the conversation with Scarlett had absolutely nothing to do with anything inappropriate, she told me about a child in her class who had been unkind to her after she had given her something, which I believe was a letter, that the child didn’t want, so she put it in the bin. Scarlett was obviously saddened by this and came home and spoke to me about it.
I asked her how she felt about it and what she had said when the child had put the letter in the bin. She said that she had felt really sad and it had made her want to cry but she felt she couldn’t say anything. This prompted me to remind her that she absolutely has a voice and she has every right to use it, if the actions of someone else had made her sad, then she should feel free and able to express this, even in a classroom environment. I feel if I don’t encourage any of my children to do this over smaller, sometimes those that even appear trivial, issues then they will feel less confident to do so if and when it really matters.
Often when people have been subjected to any kind of abuse, mental, physical, emotional, sexual, they feel their ability to exercise the right to use their voice is taken away. At the hands of any abuser, the ‘victim’ is manipulated and groomed into thinking that nothing they have to say matters, that there will be consequences if they voice what’s in their head. Another individual is responsible for taking away a very basic human right, that over time you start to believe is very normal behaviour. You become a prisoner in your own head, the feeling of claustrophobia dragging you down as your thoughts and feelings weigh heavy on your mind. Its not a pleasant place to be. And all too often it becomes too much.
For people who go through any kind of abuse as a child this behaviour often continues into adulthood and some never manage to break the cycle.
It took counselling for me to realise that actually, yes, I am Nat and I do have my own voice, and if I want to use it, I can. And now I do.
Writing the letter to the person who tormented my childhood, was the pinnacle of me realising that I wasn’t that child anymore. I had let the years of control and conditioning keep me in a place I no longer needed nor wanted to be. I did not need to hold that little girl, my inner child, hostage any longer. She was still there, just hiding, I had to help free her. I needed to find out what she needed first. And that was for someone to see her, to validate her, to let her know this wasn’t her fault and that she was going to be ok. I had to learn to forgive myself.
So here is the letter I wrote. The one that my therapist would have me read out to her and the one that would finally make me realise I was free.
“What do you think it takes to shape a person? Family, friends, life experiences, hopes, dreams?
Reading this, I would hands down bet my last pound that I was the last person you were expecting to hear from. Why could I possibly want to contact you?
I will tell you that, before we go any further, I have thought about you every single day of my life since the last time I saw you. I see you in my memories when we were small children, when playing together actually meant playing. Before ‘playing’ took on a whole new meaning.
I wonder when you last thought of me?
I wonder how you like to remember me. Do you remember me as the 13 year old that shared our last family holiday together. Laughing, joking, pretending as if nothing had ever happened between us, because that’s what we were supposed to do. Or is it that you remember me as that 11 year old confused little girl that you had such a hold over? That you loved to torment and abuse.
You know, it took me such a long time to realise that what you put me through was wrong. Do you even think about it? Do you even know what I’m talking about?
I want you to know that what you did was so fucking wrong on every possible level.
Knowing you as I do, my guess would be that you do not hold yourself accountable for anything!!You didn’t even do anything wrong did you?You were supposed to love me, like family. As a cousin. Not abuse the trust I had in you as someone I looked up to. You absolutely smashed that illusion to pieces, you betrayed me. How could you do that? How fucking dare you do that to me? You ruined my life. You took away everything I thought I knew. Your actions, yours, not mine, would mean I would grow up and not trust another living soul with anything to do with me. Absolutely nothing. Fuck, I didn’t even trust myself. I wanted to cut my wrists so badly, to bleed out, to get rid of every last trace of you. You’d tainted me, made me used. Every night I wanted to go to bed hoping in the morning I wouldn’t wake up because then it wouldn’t hurt anymore. I couldn’t hate myself if I wasn’t here. Packets of paracetamols and alcohol taken from downstairs. Is that what you wanted?To drive me to the point that wanting to die was my only escape, anything to numb the pain and heartache I felt. Why the fuck would you want to do that to someone you are supposed to love?I spent years believing that every single painstaking minute you touched me, I had wanted you to, that I had enjoyed it. Knowing that, by the time I was 11 I already knew things I shouldn’t have. I wouldn’t learn that until I was much older and come to the crushing, dawning realisation that I shouldn’t have ever experienced that with my cousin!!How could I ever possibly admit to anyone that my cousin had been the first person to do that to me!!To touch me in any other way than what was acceptable for family to do?A hug, a kiss goodbye?The thought makes me want to claw my skin off and makes me feel sick to the pit of my stomach!!I was just a baby!!!You destroyed me in every way you could. I would never have the luxury of exploring these things with anyone else for the first time because you had already taken them from me. You took them for your own sick gratification without a second thought for me. You took away things I will never and could never get back, they cannot be replaced in any way. You took away my choice, my freedom, the right to my own body. You fucking broke me. You absolutely broke me. Is that what you wanted?
I would happily give my consent to the next person I chose to be intimate with. I learnt to trust him. But that’s because it was my choice. He never pushed me. It took a long time. I couldn’t bear to be touched. I was 16, almost 17 before I’d let anyone touch me in any kind of way. But that in itself didn’t come without the crushing knowledge that none of what we were doing was a new experience for me. God how I’d wished it was. How I wish you’d just left me be. Why the fuck would you do that to me?When I said no, when I asked you to stop, why did you carry on?What about it did you enjoy the most? The fact that you were enjoying it, that it felt good or the fact that I was so fucking upset that the sobs wracked through my body and you carried on? You selfish, vindictive bastard!!Honestly, what the actual fuck??? What about that did you enjoy?What in your head made you want to do that to me?
I absolutely loathed the person you made me become!!You, your actions shaped the young adult I would grow to be. Confused, anxious, distrusting, withdrawn. Cutting every opportunity I got, starving myself so the hunger would dull the ache in my chest I would feel every day of my young life. It was how I learnt to survive the chaos in my head. All these thoughts and feelings, with no where for them to go. After all, why would someone in your family do that?Who would believe it of the golden child.
But you know what?You didn’t kill me!You may have broken me, but you failed to break the drive and determination in me to survive. The only person who can truly break me, is me!!!And I will not bow down and listen to the shit you put in my head anymore. You are the reason I loathed myself, the reason I hated my body, the way that I looked. Not any more. I am a woman with more strength than you could ever imagine and I will not let the thought of you make me any less.
Despite everything, I want you to know that I don’t hate you. I hate what you did and I hate how broken you made me feel. But I don’t hate you. What would that achieve?
But know this. I am not broken, I am not lost, I am not scared. I am me. And that you cannot take away from me.”
Its amazing what a great counsellor can help you to achieve and this really was the start of my journey to healing. Although not easy to write, to read or to speak it, it was the first step I would take to forgiving myself. I absolutely reclaimed the voice that was taken from me and I will tell you quite freely that I exercise my right to use it now at every given opportunity, because I have a lot of catching up to do.
We need to enable our children and young people. Talk to them openly and let them know that they have every right to speak about their feelings and emotions, that absolutely no one has the right to take that away from them. Create a safe place for them, let them know that it’s ok for them to tell you whatever they want to and you will listen without judgement. For if you listen to their little things, they are more likely to tell you the big things when it’s important.
So, tell your children that they are princes or princesses and that one day they will grow to be Kings and Queens, and no one, absolutely no one, has the right to dislodge their crown.
Wear it, be it, own it.
Invasion of the sleep thieves……

I know Im not alone when saying this, anyone who is a parent, or suffers from sleep disturbances will sympathise…but sleep deprivation has to be one of the worst forms of torture going.
Sleeping should be such a normal bodily function, one that is not only essential for your physical being to rest but its also hugely important for your mental well being. So when you start to miss it, it can sometimes feel like you are living in a dream world, rather than drifting off into one come the night.
From being a tiny boy Sam has always been a poor sleeper. We originally put this down to him just having serious FOMO and nothing else. We tried every sleep training you can imagine possible and for a very short period of time, he did sleep through…..some nights. His sleeping, as with everything else, has always been very sporadic. Some nights he would sleep from 5pm through to 7am, sometimes later, the next morning. Other nights he would be up every hour, shouting, knocking on our wall, knocking on the adjoining neighbours wall (its a good job we had an amazing neighbour!!) at all hours in the morning and as a result was exhausted the next day. He also always had a crippling fear of the dark, which I can’t comment on, because at the age of 32, I am still scared of the dark . But Sam’s fear has been made no easier by the fact that he now has hardly no vision at all.
At the time, I hadn’t known that sleep disturbances are part and parcel of Batten disease and it can affect patients at any age or stage of the disease. When I discovered this, it made a lot more sense as to why we had always struggled with Sam. This is I suppose, also where my deep rooted fear comes from, with regards to Alice not sleeping. And more recently that fear has become very real. She is like a carbon copy of Sam with her sleeping habits. They are both a little like Duracell bunnies, in that they just never seem to tire, ever!!What if she is affected by the same gene defect?
If Scarlett doesn’t get a good 13-14 hours of sleep, she is awful and she knows herself its because she’s tired. With Sam and Alice, Im lucky if they have a solid 5 hours some nights. Which as a result also means that I am currently running on less than that. Mixed in with insomnia, I am sometimes awake until 2-3am, in which time I have been up to and settled Alice 2 or 3 times and Sam more or less the same. And Im back up for the next day to start at 6.30.
As Sam’s condition is progressing, his sleep disturbances become more apparent, more frequent and occur for longer periods of time. Over the last few weeks, he will repetitively ask me questions before bed, like am I going downstairs, am I going in the bath, are you having dinner, are you watching a film, the list goes on. I always give him the reassurance he needs but no sooner have I got myself into bed, bath, downstairs, whatever, he is behind me asking me the same thing. So back to bed we go, and the pattern continues, for sometimes up to 2 hours before I can’t take anymore and he gets into bed with me. And he then proceeds to complain because my hair is in his face, or he doesn’t have enough cover………my bed matey.
I absolutely loathe being grumpy mummy or shouty mummy, but sleep deprivation is an absolute killer and somedays this is exactly what it makes me. It forces out the very worst in you and its awful sometimes when you reflect on this. Like in the early hours of this morning, where I’d managed to knock over the entire bedside table after getting my arm caught in the kids iPad chargers and breaking the lamp to boot, I shouted at them both and I am struggling hugely with the guilt as the morning goes on. It’s hard to remember that you aren’t that person, when it’s the dead of night and you have not one, but two children crying, and wanting your attention for various reasons and there is only one of you. I wish there was more I could do for them but I can’t split myself in half, and I will be totally honest, I really don’t enjoy sharing my bed with them. Knees in my back and elbows in my face don’t really do it for me. And I need to sleep, but I’m not entirely sure how to fix this yet.
So parents of children that don’t sleep, please know that you aren’t alone. There’s nothing worse than a smug parent who tells you their children are all magnificent sleepers and it makes you want to hot spoon them in the face, but remember, we all have our own battles to fight. Some people just like you to see their highlight reel and not what goes on behind the scenes.
And to those fighting their own battle with their own mini sleep thieves, I salute you.
Setting up camp…..

Well first blog post of 2019, I hope everyone had a wonderful Christmas and new year. Mine was very different this year. It’s the first Christmas following the separation from my husband, so learning to share the kids was a new experience. It was ok, not as horrific as I expected and the kids loved having two Christmas days. I found the days after more difficult if Im truly honest. But I tried, really hard. New year was difficult, ending in me stood in the middle of the pub balling my eyes out as the clock chimed midnight. Utterly overwhelmed by the year I’d had, I’m not sure what I felt but it was certainly not my finest moment. Sure enough there was a best friend on hand, to pick me back up again and get me home. All the love.
Those who follow my personal facebook will have seen that I had quite a significant meltdown a couple of days after Christmas. This was a culmination of things but mainly my anxieties and self doubt getting the better of me. The most important thing to come out of my counselling sessions was learning that I am not responsible for other peoples thoughts, feelings and emotions. They are responsible for those, not me. And I failed epically to remember this and allowed someone to not only dim my shine but to almost wipe it out as I seriously contemplated stopping writing my blog. I believed that what I was writing, wasn’t worth the effort and wasn’t worth reading. Fortunately, I gave my head a wobble.
I think January as a whole is hard for a lot of people. It’s the come down from the festive season and when people often feel the most alone. I struggle when the babes have gone to see their dad, its dark outside and I can’t get out for a walk to clear my head, and I’m left alone with nothing but my thoughts. Even if I have purposely kept myself busy, I find myself easily distracted and my mind wandering. Ive found more recently my anxiety has started creeping in again. Having come off my antidepressants at the back end of October, cold turkey, which I strongly advise against, Ive been managing my anxiety relatively well. These two weeks have been incredibly hard however.
Anxiety is the absolute bain of my life. As anyone who suffers will know, it tries to control your every thought and action and more often than not wins.
I chronically overthink everything, and I mean EVERYTHING. Anything from have I bought the kids enough for Christmas/birthdays?Have I told them I loved them enough today?Have they eaten enough?Do I need to do more? But the thing that drives me to complete distraction, is overthinking conversations or situations. Conversations that I’ve had that day, week, month, year, 3 years ago, 5 years ago, forever ago; what could I have said differently?What should I have said that I didn’t?Did I say something to offend that person?Could I have given them more? Could I have been more of what they needed? What if they don’t want to talk to me anymore? Do they still want to speak to me?Should I apologise?Do they even like me?
The list could go on for some considerable time. The level of anxiety I feel in these kind of situtation’s, I can only liken to those I feel when Im due to sit an exam. Sometimes I can intervene in my thought process but sometimes I’m just too far gone to try to rationalise and it ends in a true Arian meltdown, where I am angry with myself, the world and everyone in it and threaten to throw the towel in. But its short lived and I then have to deal with the guilt and regret of being so cross and short tempered. And let me tell you the guilt is real!So now you have guilt and anxiety surrounding the guilt you feel to deal with. Honestly some days it’s exhausting to be in my head.
When I am able to rationally think about it, you can’t change what’s been and gone.
So some days, weeks, months are tough. I know for one, I give myself a really, really hard time about it. I wish that I didn’t think the way I did, I wish that I could change who I am, I wish I could be more but the simple fact is, I can’t. I can’t be anything other than what I am. And nor should I want to be. I don’t make resolutions for new year, but this year I am really going to work on accepting myself for who I am.
For anyone that is out there struggling at the moment, I hear you, see you, you are not alone.
Remember sometimes it’s absolutely ok to have a meltdown, just don’t unpack and live there. Feel it, deal with it and move on. Do not let other people dim your shine simply because it is shining in their eyes.
Always be you, you are unique, you are loved, you are enough ❤
Heres to the start of 2019 xx
Dawn of a new day……

You’ve seen me talk about my counsellor in some of my previous posts but I think my counselling journey probably deserves some recognition of its own. Because for the very first time in my life I actually did something that was selfishly just for me. Not for anyone else’s benefit, not to make them happy, not to satisfy them, it was just for me.
My journey to counselling has not been an easy one. For years I snubbed the idea of it, mainly because the thought of talking to anyone about my problems was just too much and I honestly didn’t think I could be helped, that I was beyond help, that I didn’t deserve help. I wasn’t worthy. Where would I even start? My life had been like a series of unfortunate events and it would mean facing everything I had tried so hard to bury. But therein lies the problem, they were never really buried, just bubbling under the surface waiting to erupt.
When I told my husband about going for counselling, he absolutely loathed the idea. He wanted me to talk to him about my problems and only him. He couldn’t understand why I would need to go and talk to a counsellor when I could just talk to him. He’d much rather I didn’t write this blog to be blunt.
But there were things I’d kept hidden that I needed to talk about, so deeply rooted inside me, that I knew he would never be ready to hear. That no one close to me would ever be ready to hear. I needed to find a safe space, and that’s when I found Dawn.
She was recommended by a friend and I contacted her through email. She rang me the next day to make an appointment.
When I first drove to her house and parked up outside, I felt sick, my palms were clammy. Did I really want to do this?It would be so easy to just drive off and go back home.
It took every ounce of my courage to go and knock on her door and go in. We sat and she asked what I hoped she could help me with. I gave her a brief overview and she said she would be able to work with me if that was what I wanted. I knew she was the person for me, and so on my journey to healing we embarked.
Opening myself up and saying what I really feel has never been one of my strong points. Id much rather keep everyone happy, suffer alone and in silence than have someone misunderstand and judge me. The fear of disappointment and rejection is just too much for me to handle.
This ultimately stemmed back to the abuse I had endured. Over time and with clever manipulation, I believed that my opinion, my thoughts, my feelings, were irrelevant, they were unimportant, they didn’t matter, because no one would hear me, no one would see me. I, didn’t matter. I was never to tell anyone, because no one would believe me if I did.
Addressing the abuse was the biggest and most difficult step I had to take throughout my whole counselling process.
It’s one of those issues that is so hard to talk about because, firstly how do you start that conversation and secondly, I don’t want people to pity me, or see me as a victim. Im just unfortunate to be one in a long line of women who, when you dig a little deeper, have suffered at the hands of a family member, friend, partner, someone they trust. And it’s easier to keep quiet about it rather than make people feel awkward and upset. But that doesn’t invalidate any of what happened to me.
The details of my abuse, I will spare you of, as I tried to explain to my husband before he pushed me into telling him, they are bad enough in my head, why would you want them in yours?
The crippling fear about letting people in to my world was that once they knew who I really was, once they really saw me, they would leave. They would change their opinion of me and decide that because I had been abused or cut myself to survive, they would think less of me, they would think that I wasn’t worthy of their friendship, their love.
Again this was all a result of how I had been conditioned to think at the hands of someone else.
The reaction I received from my husband when pushed into sharing details I wasn’t ready to share, was exactly what I had dreaded happening but fully expected. He only reinforced the fact that the abuse was something I should be ashamed of, that no one would want to touch me. After all who would want to love me when I was so damaged?
Dawn’s job however, was to rewire my way of thinking. She noticed very quickly I had a talent for writing. I wrote poetry and found quotes to express how I felt and I decided to share it with her. On discovering that this was how I best put myself across and how I sometimes struggled with free flow talking, she got me to write letters. The first was a letter to my inner child from the adult I am today. The second was a letter from my inner child, and the third was a letter to him. I would write the letters and one by one, Dawn would ask me to read them to her. We would discuss the thought processes behind what I had written and explore the reasons I felt the way I did. The most cathartic was the letter to him. It contained everything I had ever wanted to say to him but never could or would. Within that letter and the session following, Dawn finally made me see that the shame I felt was not mine to bare, it was actually all his. His shame, his actions, his decisions, his thoughts, his feelings, projected on to me. What he had done to me over the course of time was to satisfy a need in him. It was not my fault.
It was a major breakthrough moment. I could finally give back the shame that I had so dutifully carried around for 25 years. And oh how empowering that felt. I could reclaim the voice that I so desperately needed back, as a woman, as Nat. This truly was the dawn of a new day for me (see what I did there?)
Over the course of my counselling, Dawn would provide me with the safe space I needed. She told me that space was mine to use as I wished. Some sessions I would go and not come up for air until way after my 50 minutes had passed and other sessions, I cried until I dehydrated myself. Sometimes I just needed a hug, to be held, to be seen and that was exactly what she did for me. She taught me that it was ok to acknowledge and feel my emotions, I didn’t have to try to battle them. It was ok to feel angry, hurt, upset, sad, but feel them, deal with them, let them pass and move on. This is one I am still very much working on but it helps.
For anyone that has ever been through counselling you will know what I mean when I say it feels as though your brain has never worked a day in its like before, it was the most exhausting but worthwhile process I have ever been through.
She made me realise that now I was on my journey to healing, for it was far from over yet, I had to live life for myself. Not for other people, or to make other people happy, for me.
I was not responsible for the thoughts and actions of other people, or their projections onto me. I am Nat. And that is enough.
And for now, my sessions with Dawn have come to an end but I know there is always an open door for me to go back when I need to.
Although there are some that haven’t understood my decision to seek counselling, I am so lucky to have had the open mindedness and full support from some of the most truly wonderful people. These select few, over the past year have seen every dark shadow that’s passed over me and they have never let me down. They have loved me and cared for me when I was unable to do that for myself. They’ve fed me, helped with the kids, rang, text, visited. They have given me support, advice, talked me out of panic attacks, some have talked me out of much, much worse, and some just know when to hold me so that the broken pieces of myself can start to glue themselves back together again. But they have never faltered and I will never be able to thank them enough. These are my beautiful humans. My support network.
To anyone that is thinking of counselling, my only piece of advice is to seek the right counsellor. You will know if they are the right person when you meet them. If it doesn’t feel right, you aren’t obligated to see them. Hang on for the right one. It will be worth it.
And #itsoknottobeok sometimes.
This is me…….

Tomorrow is a really poignant day. It marks a year to the date that we received Sams original diagnosis of retinal dystrophy and how we were catapulted into a world we knew nothing about.
How was it possible that my happy, healthy boy, had lost his eyesight. If only that was how things had stayed.
Tonight Sam was in the bath and I chatted with him and watched him play with his Playmobil boat, the enormity of what lies ahead for him and for us stole my breath, my lungs forgot how to breathe again and the cracks in my heart started to rip themselves open and the aching starts again. Before I could catch myself, the tears were cascading down my face like a waterfall, and I couldn’t stop them.
How long will he just be a little boy for? How long before things start to change? How quickly will he deteriorate? Will he be in any pain? How long do I have left with him?
Everyday, I see the changes in him. He stumbles over his words, he knows what he wants to say but he can’t express it the right way, he gets frustrated and upset. And of course no one can give me the answers to any of the questions I want the answers to, because just like me, they don’t know.
I know, I know, be strong for Sam, the girls, one day, one week, one month, one year at a time but some days the pain is just too real and too much to bare. I can reach out to so many people, for which I am truly thankful for and I can talk until my mouth hurts, but most aren’t living this nightmare. It’s easy when you aren’t in it. I know there are some mums who follow who are fellow Batten mums, this does not apply, you of course know how this feels.
Somedays I don’t have the energy to be strong, there’s only me and the kids here and today I am the hot mess I mentioned in my blurb at the top of my blog page.
As he climbed out of the bath and I helped him put on his Minecraft pjs, he asked me to describe what was on them. He laughed at me because I didn’t know it was an iron Golem, Im useless with Minecraft. He asked me if I was sad. I told him I was feeling a little sad today, but I was ok.
“Mummy why are you sad, you cry a lot, would you like a cuddle?You are my favourite Mummy’ and with that the sobs wracked through my body, as after the quickest hug in the world he jumped off pestering me to find his dinosaurs food and put jurassic park on for him. How am I ever supposed to be prepared for what is coming?The ever persistent thought that one day, I’m going to have to have the courage to say goodbye.
The truth is, I feel like I have failed. Its not the first time I’ve said this. I once cried on Sam’s year 2 teacher, whilst between us we were tearing our hair out trying to get some answers and told her I felt as though I was failing him because I didn’t know what was ‘wrong’. And to this day, that’s still true. I could have pushed harder, chased things up earlier, asked for second opinions, different referrals and I know to some extent she feels the same. But really what difference would it have made? We did the best we could.
I feel I have failed Sam on the most basic of levels. A mother should be able to keep her children carefree and healthy.
And I can’t do that. Yes I can make every second count with him, I can give him and his sisters beautiful memories, but I can’t do anything about Sams diagnosis, I can’t change it, take it away or make it better for him. This is completely out of my control and as his mum, I should be able to fix anything for my child. And that knowledge absolutely destroys me.
So this is me. All of me, ugly crying by myself with my man size box of tissues, not being strong, because I’m only human, and I’m doing the best I can.
My new acquaintance….

The people that really know me, know that I have a very tight circle of friends. These are the people I trust with my life, sometimes very literally, trust with my life. They are the people I want to share my good news with and the people who also know my sadness, my fears and my secrets. I do not open my heart easily and I do not give it to just anyone. These people have very much earned their places in my life and I am very lucky to have them there. Making new friends is not something I love, I will be honest, it scares me. I don’t like opening up, I hate to feel vulnerable or misunderstood. Well you remember my date with Batten’s? I’ve been making an effort to get to know them a bit better. Although I really don’t want to.
It’s been almost 3 weeks since Sams diagnosis and although some days I feel like I have my life together and everything’s going to be ok and I can deal with whatever is to come, other days its hard to see the wood for the trees. I frequently speak to people and they say ‘oh you are looking/sounding better than I thought you would’ what does that even mean?What am I supposed to look like? Granted on the days they have seen me or spoken to me, they have caught me on a good day. Given that most mornings I have to apply a full face of make up now to look anywhere half decent as insomnia wracks my body and steals my sleep, along with the eldest and youngest Evans children, who still have serious FOMO (fear of missing out) and will not sleep.
I could never begin to thank each and every person who has reached out to me after posting my blogs. The response I have had has been incredible and sometimes its when people have been brought to their knees that the spirit of human kindness really shines through. Its restored my faith in people, there is some goodness out there still.
Sam has now been referred to a Dr. Rittey at the Ryegate centre in Sheffield. A paediatric neurology specialist whose area of expertise is complex epilepsy, which is really what we are going to need looking forward to the next step of progression for Sam’s condition. Epilepsy terrifies me, it always has done. But this is something I am going to have to get a grip on and get over it to provide the best care I can for Sam when the time comes.
Having also spoken to a Batten nurse specialist at great Ormond street, I now have details of the two Batten disease specialists in London and will be able to sort a referral for Sam when we attend his appointment with Dr Rittey. This will involve travelling to London once a year to attend a multidisciplinary meeting of people who specialise in this area. This again comforts me and terrifies me in equal measure. These people are going to know exactly what they are talking about, which is great for answering any questions we may have…..but am I ready to hear the answers? Of course that’s not even a question. Im going to have to hear them whether I like it or not. This is after all, not about me, it’s about Sam.
Beside the fact that Sam doesn’t sleep and sleep deprivation is slowly eating away at my sanity, his vision has become increasingly poor over the last month or so. Today, Christmas morning, he couldn’t see any of the presents he was opening, which made my heart want to escape out of my chest and just hug him. Being the boy that he is, he would not have thanked me for this. At school the visual impairment team have been teaching Sam how to touch type and they have been teaching him Braille. It absolutely fascinates me, so clever. He’s been doing really well and demanded that the staff reward him with dinosaur certificates, which they have so very kindly indulged him in. Since Sam’s diagnosis, school have been so supportive looking for any ways which they can support him. At the moment we are all in the same boat in terms of, we don’t really know how to do that. He is coping very well with the visual impairment team in situ, and I think it will just be a case of taking it as it comes and put the support in as and when necessary. Still it’s great to have their backing and we get to keep things as normal as possible for Sam, for as long as we can.
I did something I really didn’t want to do today. I self referred our family to Bluebell wood childrens hospice. A hospice…..for my child…..again, is this even real?It doesn’t feel like it half the time. It’s something that I know I needed to do, but until I spoke to an old school friend on Christmas Eve, I didn’t know when was the right time to do it. Truth is, there is never going to be a right time for this. We are going to need their support, the girls will need their support and most importantly so will Sam. So why not now?
So 2018 is drawing to a close, Christmas is over and we look forward to the new year. Or most of us will. It’s been a whirlwind of a year and my life has been turned upside down in more ways than one. I have walked away from situations that refuse to help me grow and walked into ones that will help me flourish. But the unknown scares me. I don’t know what will happen or where we will be this time next week, next month, next year. All I know is that we survive, one day at a time. I will always give my all, my everything, for Sam, the girls and myself and look forward to the promise of new year, new beginnings.
Merry Christmas and and very happy new year xx
Better for it to happen now….
*Trigger warning* Miscarriage

For the majority of people the day you learn you are going to become a parent, your world changes. You suddenly have this incredible, tiny life growing inside you that you have created and its your job to protect it, love, care, nurture and grow it whilst its nestled safely inside you. Because as a mother, there’s only you that can do that job until baby is earth side. But what happens if that baby was never meant to make it earth side?
Miscarriage and baby loss are another of those things that as a society we don’t talk about. But why? Largely it’s a result of us feeling uncomfortable or because we don’t know how to approach the subject. As a woman who has experienced the loss of two pregnancies, the last thing I wanted was for people around me to pretend that it wasn’t happening. Or worse downplay it, like it didn’t matter, it didn’t deserve acknowledgement because it wasn’t really a baby yet, that because I’d got cancer it was better for me not to be pregnant.
By the time my first miscarriage was officially over, physically my body was wrecked and emotionally Id been left bereft by the experience I had at the hands of health professionals who refused to listen
I had a wonderful first pregnancy, textbook in fact. He even arrived 5 days before his due date and was a gorgeous bundle of chubby cheeks, thick brown hair and gorgeous brown eyes. I wanted my children close together and after 8 months I was pregnant again with baby number 2.
Overshadowed by my recent cancer diagnosis, this baby was a tiny ray of hope in what was a very dark period. Something to keep me going and along with sam, a reason to stay positive. As the weeks passed, I had no sickness or nausea, my only symptoms were tiredness and backache that I couldn’t seem to shift. But with a very active toddler, I couldn’t complain really.
When I was 12 weeks pregnant, the backache got increasingly worse and then the bleeding started. I rang through to the EPAU who couldn’t get me in for an appointment for another 4 days. They told me if the bleeding increased to go up to A&E. And that’s exactly what it did, so in A&E I ended up.
A urine sample, 4 blood vials and an internal examination later, I was told that the likelihood that I was miscarrying was high (tell me something I don’t know) and I had been booked for a scan the following morning. Although my heart already told me what I needed to know.
‘Im sorry Mrs Evans, I can’t find a heartbeat and it looks as though the baby stopped growing a few weeks ago. We’ll need to leave it 2 weeks to make sure there is definitely no signs of life or growth. In the meantime you may miscarry naturally’
Walking out of that room, I felt the crushing weight of responsibility bearing down on me. It was my job to grow this baby and I had failed. My body could successfully grow a tumour, but had failed to protect and grow my baby. What was wrong with me? Id managed it the first time round, so why couldn’t I do it this time?
I was back to playing the waiting game. For two weeks, I tortured myself for being inadequate, whilst being crippled by pain and bleeding heavily, just to give me a daily reminder that I was having an ‘unsuccessful pregnancy’ and I was a failure.
After two weeks, I attended clinic again and was given another scan, that only confirmed that I’d had a missed abortion or missed miscarriage. Where your body continues to think that it’s pregnant but the embryo stops growing. I really had failed. My body had conned me into thinking I was still pregnant for 6 weeks after my baby had stopped growing. And it would prove that it was adamant it wasn’t going to let go.
After the scan, I had to sit with a nurse and make a decision about what route I wanted to take to rid my body of its retained products of conception…….I absolutely loathe this term. In the words of Dr Seuss, a life is a life, no matter how small. Products are something you buy in a supermarket, not a life that could have been.
I was given the choice of miscarrying naturally (clearly my body wasn’t doing a very good job of that) medical or surgical management. I didn’t want the medical management, having seen the procedure and understanding the process, it wasn’t something I would have ever chosen. The nurse was wonderful and told me it was my body, my choice. I opted for surgical management, I would be away for a few hours all being well and then home again with Sam, I hated being away from him. She booked me in on the emergency list for the following day.
I was nil by mouth from midnight that night and made my way onto the ward for 7am. A doctor came to book me in and cannulate and consent me. She failed 4 times to get a cannula in, I could have done it better myself. And that’s where I would wait until my slot for surgery. 1pm came and with it arrived the surgeon on the ward…..telling a nurse how happy she was to be finished……the nurse saw me looking confused, so she queried why I hadn’t been called for surgery. Apparently my name wasn’t on the list. She pulled my notes and began looking through the epau ones. Approaching me with the kind of self assuredness that surgeons tend to have she announced that as I was only technically 6 weeks pregnant, I was more suitable for medical management so that’s what we’d go with, she signed off some paperwork and with that she was gone……hang on a minute……that is absolutely not what I signed up for. And yet a few hours later, that’s exactly what I found myself having.
A Dr arrived to give me the first pessary. I couldn’t move for a period of time afterwards so I fell into a fitful sleep, not having eaten or drunk for almost 24 hours.
Then came the dawning realisation of what was coming next; the soul destroying task of having to use the toilet. Anyone who has been through this experience will know and remember the feeling all too well.
Having to use a bed pan liner to catch whatever your body decides to pass for you to then hand to a nurse to examine…..every time you go to the toilet. This was part of the process that I had wanted to avoid. It is not pleasant for anyone involved. And yet again here I was, doing the thing I didn’t want because my choice had been taken away from me.
By the next morning, I had failed to pass anything pregnancy related, so I would need another pessary. More waiting and another day away from my little boy. My husband wasn’t allowed to stay so this experience was one I endured on my own from start to finish, with no pain relief other than paracetamols.
The next pessary was put in, another 12 hours were allowed for it to work, and the surgeon that had refused my surgical procedure had said that if this pessary didn’t work Id have to go to theatre, so continue to starve me…….say again lady???So after all this, I could end up in theatre anyway and I still wasn’t allowed to eat! I was so frustrated and angry. Frustrated that this was not what I had asked for, frustrated that my body refused to comply, angry that they had put me through something I didn’t want. I was stuck in hospital, away from home and I absolutely hated it.
And of course, after 12 hours, my body had refused to part with absolutely anything.
By this time it was visiting hours. The surgeon of course chose then to come back round to review me. She asked if she could give me a quick examination to see what was going on…..in the middle of visiting. I gave my consent, albeit grudgingly, I just wanted this over so I could go home. Upon thorough examination she declared that she could see something and was going to remove it……what?Now?In the middle of visiting?And with that she began. I cannot even begin to describe the pain I would then endure. I lay on that bed, with just curtains separating me from the rest of the ward, holding a nurses hand and biting my arm to stop myself from making any noise as hot tears rolled down my face.
This would be one of the most degrading experiences of my life. After a good 5 minutes, she declared that she ‘thought she had it all’ she would book me in for a follow up scan and I was free to go. I felt so violated and so very much alone. Topped off by another doctor asking how I would like to dispose of my ‘products’, would a mass burning be suitable?I was mortified.
At home the effects of the miscarriage started to take its toll on me. My body felt bruised and tired. I felt so empty, like a part of me had been taken and I would never get it back. From a medical point of view I know miscarriages usually happen because the pregnancy is not viable for any number of reasons. But that knowledge didn’t fill the void I now felt.
The grief of never knowing what could have been and the overwhelming sadness that I had failed consumed every minute of my day.
Then rolled in the comments:
‘Well its better for it to have happened now rather than later’
‘Think yourself lucky you’ve already got a baby’
‘You can always try again’
‘Its fine, its not like it was a baby yet anyway’
‘Its only like a really heavy period, get over it’
People generally mean well, I know, but please think before you speak. You are talking to a person that is grieving after a loss. No matter how early or late that loss is. Offer comfort, support, love, understanding. Physically and mentally they are recovering from something that unless you have been through it, you can’t possibly understand how difficult it really is.
It makes me incredibly sad that an experience that was already hard, was made harder by my voice being taken from me and my choices not acknowledged by people you put your trust into. It took two months to finally get the all clear. If they had done what id opted for, the procedure and experience would have been over in the same day, with less trauma left in its wake.
And as for you little one, that tiny little being, that was so swiftly here then gone, you will always be my favourite ‘what if?